For years, the cottage that Charlie Fisher and Rebecca Irwin owned in Amagansett, N.Y., was all they desired in a second residence. At 1,200 sq. toes, the Nineteen Sixties construction was nothing fancy, however after a fundamental renovation it was interesting sufficient to be featured in Dwell, and so they treasured each sunny day they may escape to it from Manhattan with their three younger kids.
Over time, circumstances modified. As their kids grew up — Henry is now 21, Emily is nineteen and Grace is 14 — the home started to really feel cramped. Mr. Fisher, 52, now the chief monetary officer of a expertise start-up, and Ms. Irwin, 51, who works in finance, superior of their careers. And so they started to lengthy for a bit of extra privateness after dwelling for therefore lengthy in a home hemmed in by neighbors.
“It was an awesome spot, and we liked it,” Mr. Fisher mentioned. “We simply outgrew it.”
For one thing with extra space indoors and out, they started dreaming of constructing a home from scratch. The query was the place.
More and more, they discovered themselves driving east, to Montauk. “I’m a really enthusiastic however very mediocre surfer, so I used to be going out to Ditch Plains so much,” Mr. Fisher mentioned. “And we had been spending time there mountain climbing and simply having fun with the fantastic thing about the realm.”
So when their actual property agent, Krae Van Sickle, of Saunders & Associates, instructed a five-acre hilltop property simply north of Ditch Plains Seashore, they had been intrigued.
“What we discovered after we received there was this unbelievable spot,” Mr. Fisher mentioned. “It’s one of many greater, if not the very best, factors in Montauk, the place you will have 360-degree views out to Block Island Sound, all the way in which out to the lighthouse, to the ocean to south after which out throughout Lake Montauk.”
The lot got here with a rundown Fifties home they knew they’d ultimately tear down, but it surely allowed the couple to promote the Amagansett home and have a spot to remain as they started designing a brand new residence with an architect.
They purchased the property in December 2014 for about $5.1 million, and moved in. Then they referred to as Paul Masi, a fellow surfer and the principal of East Hampton-based Bates Masi + Architects, whose work they’d lengthy admired. After visiting the property, Mr. Masi conceived a plan to emphasise the views by including earth to extend the peak of the hilltop and putting in a pair of granite retaining partitions to include a big portion of the dwelling house throughout the mound.
“Not solely do these retaining partitions let you inhabit the bottom, however in addition they slice into the panorama and arrange these vignettes of various elements of the view,” Mr. Masi mentioned.
The lounge, eating space and kitchen of the 5,350-square-foot home are nestled between the retaining partitions and enclosed on the opposite two sides by floor-to-ceiling sliding-glass panels. When the climate is heat, the glass partitions could be rolled out of the way in which, making the middle of the house really feel like a lined out of doors house. (Screens could be pulled throughout to maintain bugs out.)
From there, the home climbs up. On one aspect is a den with a staircase ascending to the first suite; on the opposite is a second two-story wing containing 5 bedrooms, a mudroom and a lounge. As a result of every wing has its decrease degree buried within the hill, from the surface they resemble single-story cottages with gable roofs.
For many of the inside, Bates Masi envisioned minimalist particulars and hardwearing supplies like break up and tumbled granite, whitewashed oak and uncovered metal. Aiming to make sure a cushty really feel, Mr. Fisher and Ms. Irwin employed Jenna Chused, of the New York-based interiors agency Chused & Co., to assist choose ornamental finishes, furnishings, lighting and artwork.
“They wished a softness to the home,” Ms. Chused mentioned. “The thought was to make it really feel comfy and opulent, however nonetheless like a seaside home.”
Within the main lavatory, she chosen concrete tile from Tabarka Studio with a white-and-black sample and inlaid brass particulars for the ground; tadelakt plaster for the partitions; and comely mirrors by Gio Ponti to hold above the vainness. She furnished the lounge with sculptural, lacquered nesting espresso tables by Pierre Augustin Rose, an enormous Howard sectional couch from Egg Collective and classic chairs by Jindrich Halabala. Across the eating desk, she added deep upholstered seats from Thomas Hayes beneath a pair of classic pendant lamps she discovered at a Paris flea market. And within the kitchen, she labored with the couple to customise each cupboard and drawer to mirror how they might use the house.
After demolishing the previous home in December 2017, Advantage Builders had made sufficient progress on the brand new one by the summer time of 2019 that Mr. Fisher and Ms. Irwin might use it, whilst ending touches continued into November 2020. The whole value was roughly $6 million.
Now that it’s full, “we’re thrilled,” Mr. Fisher mentioned. “And one of many silver linings throughout Covid was that we received to stay there in a method we hadn’t anticipated. We envisioned it as extra of a summer time home, however we’ve been capable of be there by all of the seasons. In winter, there are fireplaces all through and it’s heat and comfortable.”
And in summer time, there’s browsing, in fact — though being nearer to Ditch Plains hasn’t executed a lot to enhance Mr. Fisher’s expertise. “Nonetheless mediocre in any case these years,” he lamented. “However nonetheless enthusiastic.”
For weekly e mail updates on residential actual property information, enroll right here.